×

Have you tried Pickleball yet? Try it at the Access Event Centre. Equipment provided!

For more info, click here.

The Border Road issue in Rhineland Municipality could end up being settled by the Supreme Court of Canada.

The road is located north of the Manitoba and North Dakota border in Rhineland and was constructed in the 1940s and has been built up over the past number of decades.

A group of North Dakota farmers and local municipalities contend that the road is actually a dike that impedes the natural flow northward of floodwater from the Pembina River into Manitoba and has caused extensive damage to crops, fields and local infrastructure on the American side for several decades.

The plaintiffs brought their case before a federal judge in Winnipeg in 2016, seeking financial compensation for the damage and removal of the road. The judge, in that case, border road2 2011An aerial view of the border roaddecided he could not provide a ruling on the dispute because the issue was outside the federal court's jurisdiction, based on the terms of the International Boundary Waters Treaty Act.

The matter was taken to the Canadian Federal Court of Appeal, which sided with the federal judge and ruled that the issue was outside the court's jurisdiction.

"We are currently looking at our options and I believe an appeal to Canadian Supreme Court is imminent," said Robert Fleming, the lawyer representing the North Dakota group. "We have to request leave from the court to appeal and I think the deadline for that is August 1st, or somewhere in that neighbourhood."

Fleming feels they have a strong case based on the articles contained within the Boundary Waters Treaty. That document, which goes back over 100 years, lays out the rights and responsibilities of both the United States and Canada for resolving any dispute over any waters bordering the two countries. This particular case centres on waters that spill over from the Pembina River during a flood and are blocked from their natural flow north into Manitoba by the road.

"This spring was a good example. We had a tremendous flood in Pembina County that was contained to the northernmost three miles of the county because that water could not get back to Canada. They can call it a road, but it's really a dike, and it sits there and pushes that water onto farmland heading east and that's not going to change until that dike comes down," according to Fleming.

Fleming is upset with the Manitoba government and Rhineland Municipality for allowing this issue to drag out over the last 12 years without any effort to resolve it.

"This is simply a local issue that has now escalated to nationwide issue and I'm not sure why the Province of Manitoba and Municipality of Rhineland have dug in their heels and not tried to do something to alleviate this issue and enter into good faith negotiations with us on getting it taken care of. I'd like to see us sit down with the powers that be and get this hammered out, because there needs to be a resolution."

Fleming is afraid that if they don't receive relief on the Border Road issue through the courts it's very possible someone will take matters into their own hands during a future flood event.

"Because the only other option is a backhoe with a big bucket during the springtime, and that's not going to work in the favour of either country," said Fleming.

×

Have you tried Pickleball yet? Try it at the Access Event Centre. Equipment provided!

For more info, click here.

More Local News

Police and Fire Crews Respond to Two Car Crash in Altona

Emergency crews were called to a mid-morning collision Thursday in Altona. The incident appeared to have been between two vehicles at the intersection of PR 30 and Centre Ave. on the east side of…

Winkler's Nature Sanctuary Has New Name, Big Plans (Gallery)

Winkler's nature sanctuary has a bright future ahead of it. The newly named Discovery Nature Sanctuary offers a unique experience for those living in the city says Paul Goossen, Chair of the…

Pembina Valley's Hidden Poverty Revealed During Forum In Carman

Carman United Church hosted a public forum Tuesday to discuss poverty in the Pembina Valley as part of the Canadian Poverty Reduction Strategy. One of the organizers, Minister Karen Tjaden of…

Access Credit Union S.V.P. and C.O.O Takes On Stars Rescue On The Island

Myrna Wiebe, Senior Vice President and Chief Operating Officer with Access Credit Union (ACU) is raising money for STARS Air Ambulance. The fundraiser called STARS Rescue on the Island will airlift…

Health Minister Says Announcements Of Changes Largely Completed

Health Minister Kelvin Goertzen says he has finished all of the major announcements regarding the changes in the delivery of health care in Manitoba. Goertzen adds that while change is constant in…

Altona And Australian Sunflower Queens Prepare For 2017 Festival

The Australian Central Highlands Easter Sunflower Festival Queen is visiting Altona. Anna Rixon was crowned Easter Sunflower Queen in Emerald, Australia and will be participating in the Manitoba…

Municipalities Benefit From Provincial Road Funding

The province is helping to pay for a handful of road improvement projects in Pembina Valley and Red River Valley. 188 projects in 99 municipalities across Manitoba were approved for money through the…

UPDATE: Moped Accident In Winkler (VIDEO)

Emergency service crews including Winkler Police and Winkler Fire responded to an accident on 1st St. in Winkler Tuesday afternoon. The accident appears to have occurred at the corner of 1st St. and…

Improved Safety Behind Stanley Hwy 32 Paving Project

The RM of Stanley Council has formed a partnership with Manitoba Infrastructure and Transportation (MIT) on a pair of projects to be completed this summer. The two sections of road are on PTH 32…

Morden Police Seeking Help To Identify Suspected Shoplifters

The theft of a PlayStation 4 from Shoppers Drug Mart in Morden ended up being only a portion of items taken by the suspects in the case. The PlayStation theft was previously reported by Morden Police…

Worldwide 4-H Members Gather In Ottawa

Thirty-five 4-H representatives from Manitoba attended the Global 4-H Summit that took place in Ottawa, Ont. from July 11 to 14. Youth delegates at the 2017 Global 4-H Summit in Ottawa, Ont.Over 500…

Province Backs W.C. Miller Gym Project

"We finally got our gym for W.C. Miller!" said Craig Smiley excitedly following an announcement Tuesday that the Province will help fund construction of a new gym at the Altona high school. "We are…

Altona Man Gets Jail Time for Child Porn

An Altona man has received four years in jail after pleading guilty to making and possessing child pornography. The mid-30 year old was originally arrested in December 2014. A number of additional…

Non-Life Threatening Injuries Sustained in Highway 75 Rollover

RCMP responded to a single vehicle collision near Emerson Tuesday afternoon. A semi trailer traveling in the southbound lane on Highway 75 entered the ditch and rolled approximately two miles north…

Stage To Be Ready For Harvest Festival Weekend

As the 2017 Winkler Harvest Festival weekend draws closer, so does the completion of the main stage renovation project. Festival backstage and hospitality director Eva Harder says they've been told…

Scam Puts Local Woman At Risk Of Losing $2,500

Winkler Police recently received a complaint from a woman who believes she was the victim of fraud after attempting to purchase a vehicle online. The woman used a company based in Newfoundland which…

Medical Officer Of Health Says Awareness Key To Easier Breathing

Forest fires burning in B.C. and Alberta have been a factor in reduced air quality in recent weeks, including here in Southern Manitoba. That on top on heat can be a major irritant for people,…

7-6 Ranch Steak And Lobster Fest Has Record Setting Year

The 17th annual 7-6 Ranch Steak and Lobster Fest near Carman raised its highest amount to date this year. In excess of $75,000 was raised this year explained event host Debbie Middleton. "We have…

Possible Water Service Interruption Scheduled For PVWC Members

Some slight maintenance work could create a possible disruption in service to Pembina Valley Water Co-op customers tonight. CEO Greg Archibald says a meter is being changed at the Letellier treatment…

New Clothing Store Brings Added Options And Variety To Winkler

The newest clothing store in Winkler, PV Threads, held its Grand Opening this past weekend. Owner Trudy Wiebe explains she wanted to bring more clothing store options to the region. Wiebe began by…

PembinaValleyOnline.com is your only local source for community news and information such as weather and classifieds.

Search the Biz Guide

23
Jul
2017
Dog Town Sunday Market

23 July 2017 - 29 October 2017, 10:00 am - 5:00 pm

Dog Town





23
Jul
2017
Plum Coulee VBS

23 July 2017 - 27 July 2017, 6:30 pm - 6:30 pm

Plum Coulee Bergthaler Mennonite Church, Plum Coulee





24
Jul
2017
Summer Art Camp - Week 2

24 July 2017 - 28 July 2017, 1:00 pm - 3:00 pm

Pembina Hills Arts Council, Morden





25
Jul
2017
Summer Art Camp - Pottery

25 July 2017 - 04 August 2017, 10:00 am - 12:00 pm

Pembina Hills Arts Council, Morden





26
Jul
2017
Try it: Taekwondo

26 July 2017 - 27 July 2017, 7:00 pm - 8:30 pm

Morden Access Event Centre, Morden





26
Jul
2017
Yoga in the Village (Neubergthal)

26 July 2017 - 27 July 2017, 7:00 pm - 8:00 pm

Village of Neubergthal, Halbstadt





27
Jul
2017
Volunteer Driver Workshop - Winkler & District Handi-Van

27 July 2017 9:00 am - 4:00 pm

Winkler Senior Centre, Winkler





Login